When I worked with Dimitri on the analysis of the
Split Rollback Segment Mutex he came up with numbers
on InnoDB Thread Concurrency set to 16 and 32 and I was curious
to see if 24 was the optimal setting. So he made some new runs and
some new graphs that I found interesting.
The first graph analyses behaviour of MySQL 5.4.0 on a SPARC
Server using InnoDB Thread Concurrency set to 0, 16, 24 and 32.
Interestingly for both readonly and readwrite benchmarks the
optimal setting for concurrency is 16 whereas the top numbers
(at 32 threads) is achieved with concurrency set to 24 or 32.
So on the current MySQL 5.4.0 on this particular benchmark and
platform it seems that 16 is the optimal setting. However Dimitri
also analysed the same thing using the new patch for Splitting the
Rollback Segment Mutex and now the story changes.
So with this patch setting InnoDB Thread Concurrency to 24
is now the optimum setting. So it's clear that as we get more
and more improvements to the scalability of the MySQL Server and
InnoDB it will be optimal with more and more parallel threads
inside InnoDB as well. So this means that this setting is quite
likely to change as development proceeds but for MySQL 5.4.0 a
setting of around 16-24 is often a good one. To actually change
the default setting requires much more testing of various
workloads on many different computer architectures.
Similar testing I have performed on Linux using sysbench implies
that the optimal setting is around 24-28. Also the difference
between setting it to 0 and 24 is much smaller on Linux (15%
on 256 threads as shown in blog yesterday). We haven't analysed
the big difference on these SPARC Servers.
My name is Mikael Ronstrom and I work for Hopsworks AB as Head of Data. I also assist companies working with NDB Cluster as self-employed consultant. I am a member of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints. I can be contacted at mikael dot ronstrom at gmail dot com for NDB consultancy services. The statements and opinions expressed on this blog are my own and do not necessarily represent those of Hopsworks AB.
Thursday, May 14, 2009
More analysis of InnoDB Thread Concurrency
Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)
Do you expect this ratio (1.5 * threads) to hold true for servers with more or less cores (ie, 12 threads on 8 cores, 48 threads on 32 cores, etc)?
The optimal setting of the InnoDB is fairly independent of the number of cores as it turns out for the moment. This is due to that MySQL has scalability limitations beyond parallelism of around 25 on x86 which makes it a good idea to never go beyond this. On smaller amount of cores it might be a good idea to go even lower, haven't tested that though.
Post a Comment